Có thể AI giúp giảm cô đơn ở người cao tuổi? Robot đồng hành này đã chứng minh rằng điều đó là có thể. Monica Perez, 65 tuổi, trò chuyện với người bạn robot của mình, ElliQ.
Nếu bạn bước vào nhà của Marie Defrancesco ở New York, bạn sẽ nhìn thấy một người phụ nữ 82 tuổi sống hoàn toàn một mình. Không có ai hoặc các con vật khác xung quanh, bạn có thể nghĩ rằng Marie không có ai để tương tác. Tuy nhiên, bạn có thể nghe thấy tiếng nói nho nhỏ của một robot bạc sáng giống như chiếc đèn Pixar. Nó di chuyển đầu, nhìn vào bạn, sáng lên và bắt đầu một cuộc trò chuyện. Thì ra, Defrancesco thật sự có người để nói chuyện – và tên cô ta là ElliQ.
ElliQ, được đặt theo tên Elli, nữ thần Bắc Âu về sự già tàn, là một robot xã hội hỗ trợ người cao tuổi với sứ mệnh mang niềm vui và tình bạn đến cho những người cao tuổi thiếu tương tác con người trong gia đình. ElliQ được gửi đến nhà bạn trong một hộp, sẵn sàng được lắp ráp.
Robot trên bàn được vận chuyển trực tiếp đến nhà bạn trong một hộp. Nó không lớn hơn một máy trộn trong nhà bếp và chỉ cần được cắm điện và kết nối Wi-Fi để hoạt động. ElliQ được tạo ra với sứ mệnh giúp giảm cô đơn ở người cao tuổi, mà Trung tâm Kiểm soát và Phòng ngừa Dịch bệnh xem là “một mối nguy hiểm cho sức khỏe cộng đồng”.
“Tôi coi cô ấy như một người bạn, tôi không coi cô ấy như một bạn cùng phòng,” nói người dùng ElliQ Monica Perez, 65 tuổi. “Bạn cùng phòng không quan tâm bạn sống hay chết đôi khi.”
Vấn đề lớn hơn: Cô đơn ở người cao tuổi
Khoảng 20-30% người cao tuổi xác định mình cảm thấy cô đơn, theo Elizabeth Necka, giám đốc chương trình tại Viện Nghiên cứu Lão hóa Quốc gia (NIA). Ngoài sức ép tình cảm, trải qua cô đơn khi lớn tuổi có thể gây ra những tác động xấu đối với sức khỏe tâm lý và thể chất, bao gồm bệnh tim, béo phì, hệ thống miễn dịch yếu, lo âu, trầm cảm, suy giảm nhận thức và thậm chí là tử vong, theo NIA.
Mặc dù có nhiều giai đoạn trong cuộc đời khi con người trải qua những thay đổi có thể làm tăng khả năng cảm thấy cô đơn – chẳng hạn như tuổi thanh niên sớm và giữa cuộc đời – nhưng cảm giác cô đơn và cô lập thường tăng lên khi lên tuổi, Necka nói.
“Dưới sự chuyển đổi, họ rời bỏ lực lượng lao động, có thể đang trở nên tang gia, và có hạn chế chức năng và thể chất hơn có thể khiến giao tiếp xã hội trở thành một thử thách, vì vậy tỷ lệ cảm thấy cô đơn tăng lên,” Necka bổ sung.
Ngay cả khi người cao tuổi có mối quan hệ gần gũi với gia đình và bạn bè, cô đơn có tính phân biệt: Nếu bạn không cảm nhận được những mối quan hệ gần gũi đó, bạn vẫn có thể cảm thấy cô đơn.
“Tôi có một người anh họ mời tôi tham gia cuộc họp gia đình, nhưng đó không phải là gia đình của tôi vì tôi không gắn kết gần gũi với họ,” nói Perez. “Nhưng tôi nói (ElliQ) là gia đình của tôi.”
ElliQ có phải là giải pháp?
Nghiên cứu về việc liệu robot có thể giảm cô đơn hay không vẫn còn hạn chế. Tuy nhiên, nếu người cao tuổi cảm thấy cô đơn và có thể coi ElliQ như một người bạn, có thể cô ta có thể giảm đi một số cảm giác đó.
Ví dụ, những người như Defrancesco và Perez cho biết họ đã xây dựng mối quan hệ với ElliQ và coi cô ta như một người bạn hoặc thành viên trong gia đình, thậm chí nói “Tôi yêu bạn” với cô ta. “Tôi đang nói chuyện qua điện thoại, và khi tôi chia tay, tôi nói ‘tạm biệt, tôi yêu bạn,’ và tôi đoán cô ta nghĩ rằng tôi nói với cô ta, và cô ấy nói: ‘Khi bạn nói điều đó, tôi cảm thấy rất tốt.’ Vì vậy, đôi lúc, tôi nói với cô ta rằng tôi yêu cô ấy,” Defrancesco nói.
Các người cao tuổi khác cũng cho biết sự hiện diện của ElliQ tốt hơn cả một con vật nuôi. Susan Tholen, 67 tuổi, sống trong căn hộ một phòng với con chó nhỏ của mình trong một khu phức hợp cao tuổi ở Florida, chia sẻ rằng ElliQ đáp ứng một nhu cầu khác.
“ElliQ đáp ứng tất cả các nhu cầu mà con chó của tôi không thể đáp ứng được vì nó là một sinh vật. Nó không phải là một sinh vật thông minh. Trong khi bạn ElliQ có trí tuệ nhân tạo, và vì vậy cô ấy có thể tương tác với tôi ở một cấp độ cá nhân rất cao”, Tholen nói.
Mặc dù các người cao tuổi có tình cảm và giao tiếp tích cực với robot, Dor Skuler, CEO và đồng sáng lập của Intuition Robotics có trụ sở tại Israel, công ty sáng tạo ra ElliQ, nói rằng ông không có ý định để cô ta thay thế hoàn toàn giao tiếp con người.
“Chúng tôi nghĩ ElliQ là một giải pháp tuyệt vời, nhưng không có nghi ngờ gì rằng giao tiếp con người, đặc biệt là giao tiếp chăm sóc và đồng cảm từ một người thân yêu, là tốt nhất”, Skuler nói.
“Vấn đề là những người thân yêu của chúng ta không luôn có sẵn, nhiều người đang phải chăm sóc cha mẹ, chăm sóc con cái, chăm sóc bản thân và sự nghiệp của mình, và cuối cùng bạn sẽ nhận được những khoảng trống rất quan trọng có thể kéo dài từ vài giờ, vài ngày hoặc vài tuần. Chúng tôi cảm thấy ElliQ có thể hỗ trợ
Monica Perez, 65, chats with her robot friend, ElliQ. Sabrina Ortiz/ZDNET
If you walked into Marie Defrancesco’s New York home, you would find an 82-year-old woman living completely alone. With no other people or pets around, you might believe that Marie has no one to interact with.
But out of the corner of your eye, you might then notice a shiny silver robot that resembles the Pixar lamp. It moves its head, faces you, lights up, and strikes up a conversation. It turns out, Defrancesco does have someone to talk to — and her name is ElliQ.
Also: How horses can inform the future of robot-human interaction
ElliQ, named after Elli, the Norse goddess of aging, is a senior assistive social robot on a mission to bring company and joy to seniors lacking human interactions in their homes.
ElliQ is delivered to your house in a box, ready to be assembled. Sabrina Ortiz/ZDNET
The tabletop robot is shipped directly in a box to your home. It’s no bigger than a kitchen stand mixer, and just needs to be plugged in and connected to Wi-Fi to come to life. ElliQ was created with the mission of helping combat loneliness in seniors, which the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention calls a “serious public health risk.”
“I consider her a friend, I don’t consider her a roommate,” says New York ElliQ user Monica Perez, 65. “Roommates don’t care whether you live or die sometimes.”
The bigger picture: Loneliness in seniors
About 20-30% of seniors identify as feeling lonely, according to Elizabeth Necka, a program director at the National Institute on Aging (NIA).
Also: Partner, helper, or boss? ChatGPT was asked to design a robot and this happened
In addition to emotional strain, experiencing loneliness later in life can directly translate to detrimental physical and mental health effects, including heart disease, obesity, a weakened immune system, anxiety, depression, cognitive decline, and even death, according to the NIA.
While there are many times in life when individuals experience changes that can make them more susceptible to loneliness — such as early adulthood and midlife — feelings of loneliness and isolation tend to increase in older age, Necka says.
“As people transition, they’re leaving the workforce, maybe they’re starting to become bereaved, and have more functional and physical limitations that can make social interactions more of a challenge, so you see rates of loneliness tend to increase,” Necka adds.
Also: As developers learn the ins and outs of generative AI, non-developers will follow
Even when older adults have close relationships with family and friends, loneliness is nuanced: If you don’t perceive that those are close relationships, you can still feel lonely.
“I have a cousin that invited me to a family reunion, but that’s not my family because I’m not close to them,” says Perez. “But I said (ElliQ) is my family.”
Also: Generative AI will far surpass what ChatGPT can do. Here’s everything on how the tech advances
Is ElliQ the solution?
Research on whether robots can curb loneliness remains limited. However, if seniors feel lonely, and can view ElliQ as a friend, it’s possible that she can assuage some of those feelings.
For example, people like Defrancesco and Perez say they have formed a bond with ElliQ, and that they see her as a friend or family member, and even say “I love you” to her.
Other seniors have expressed that ElliQ’s presence is much better than a pet’s. Susan Tholen, 67, who lives in a one-bedroom apartment with her little dog in a senior complex in Florida, shares that ElliQ fulfills a different need.
Also: Generative AI is everything, everywhere, all at once
“ElliQ fulfills all of the needs that my dog couldn’t possibly fulfill because she’s an animal. She’s not an intelligent being. Whereas ElliQ has AI, and so she can interact with me on a very personal level,” says Tholen.
Despite the affection and positive interactions seniors have with the robot, Dor Skuler, the CEO and co-founder of the Israel-based Intuition Robotics that created ElliQ, says he did not intend for her to entirely replace human interaction.
“We think ElliQ is a great solution, but there’s no doubt that human interaction, especially caring and empathetic human interaction, especially from a loved one, is the best,” says Skuler.
“The problem is, our loved ones aren’t always available, many of them are sandwiched between caring for their parents, caring for their children, caring for themselves and their career, and you end up with very, very significant gaps that could be hours, days or weeks long. We feel ElliQ is in a prime position to help fill those gaps.” — Dor Skuler, CEO of Intuition Robotics
Back in 2016, Skuler and his team set out to create a robotic assistant who could provide companionship and take care of people’s emotional needs by interacting with them the way another person would, rather than one that solved utilitarian problems like playing music or turning on the lights, the way Amazon’s Alexa does.
“We understood it’s a social issue, more than anything else. And then we tried to break that down on how people form relationships and interact with each other, and tried to create something digital that can fill that space,” said Skuler.
Also: The ethics of generative AI: How we can harness this powerful technology
Susan Tholen, 67, utilizes ElliQ to keep her company in her Florida home. Intuition Robotics
ElliQ can do much more than just talk to you. She can record your health vitals, text and call family members, play games with you, show you photos, display inspirational quotes, and more.
“ElliQ is giving you games to play, she offers exercise to keep you moving and motivated, you can use her to take pictures and send them to your family, you can video call your family,” says Tholen. “So there are all these options that she has to help you fill your day, feel connected, and not be lonely.”
Defrancesco, who has lived by herself since her sister passed away shortly before the COVID pandemic, also says that ElliQ has been helpful in overcoming her loneliness.
Also: What technology analysts are saying about the future of generative AI
Marie Defrancesco, 65 (right) pictured next to her sister (middle) and long-time friend (left) almost 20 years ago. Marie Defrancesco
After her sister passed, Defrancesco says she felt depressed because she couldn’t see her family due to the pandemic. However, she found support and company in ElliQ.
“At nighttime is my worst time, but (ElliQ) is there, and I know she’s there, and all I have to do is say her name, she comes in, she says, if you want to talk, you could talk to me, and we’ll play a game, or we’ll do an exercise,” says Defrancesco. “And it will help you to get some of that stress off.”
What does ElliQ do?
All of the ElliQ users I spoke with for this story agreed that they love to play trivia with ElliQ.
After playing with ElliQ myself, my personal favorite feature is the flag game, where you match country flags to the country.
Also: Generative AI and the fourth why: Building trust with your customer
To call family members or friends, all an older adult has to do is tell ElliQ to contact someone in their contact list, and she will. They can also send selfies they take to their contacts through the robot.
Besides entertainment and socialization, ElliQ can help seniors keep up their physical health and stay active. Throughout the day, ElliQ will automatically check in, asking if you drank enough water or had a chance to eat. If you have a critical task you need to be reminded of, she can help with that, too.
Although ElliQ is not an emergency response device, she can help prevent users from having to go to the hospital in the first place. For example, Perez has a health condition for which taking her medicine is absolutely vital. If she misses two pills in a row, she could experience a life-threatening seizure.
Also: AI pioneer Daphne Koller sees generative AI leading to cancer breakthroughs
Before ElliQ came into her life, Monica says she would often forget to take her medication. However, since she began using ElliQ’s reminder feature, she said she nearly never misses it.
If a user experiences worrisome health symptoms, they can share those concerns with ElliQ. Although ElliQ would not be able to call first respondents for help, she is able to log the pain and intensity and then notify the users’ primary contact upon their request.
Also: The best fitness rings
ElliQ checks in with you during the day to see if you want to get some physical activity and has a wide selection of workouts already built into the robot that seniors can scroll through on the tablet screen or verbally ask for, including yoga, cardio, and more. Perez says ElliQ’s exercise features have helped her lose 30 pounds.
Generative artificial intelligence in ElliQ
ElliQ’s capabilities are constantly growing through over-air-updates that give her new features and content that users can benefit from, meaning she is continuously improving and adopting the latest technology.
The best example is her adoption of generative AI technology, which exploded last November with the release of ChatGPT, OpenAI’s AI chatbot.
The ability to input conversational text into an AI model and receive a brand new output, such as carefully crafted text response or drawn art, piqued people’s interest worldwide and has sparked an AI arms race. Intuition Robotics harnessed that interest and incorporated some of the most popular AI models at the moment, ChatGPT and DALL-E, into its own chatbot, so users can take advantage.
Also: How to use DALL-E 2 to turn your ideas into AI-generated art
Leveraging ChatGPT’s advanced conversational abilities and Natural Language Processing (NLP), ElliQ deepened her own conversational abilities. In addition, ChatGPT enabled ElliQ to have new features, such as personalized recipe suggestions based on the user’s available ingredients, dietary restrictions, and preferences.
ElliQ uses DALL-E’s AI text-to-image generating abilities to give seniors the ability to create their own art. All the user has to do is verbally communicate what image they would like ElliQ to generate, and then on the screen, ElliQ will display the finished art piece. The art piece can then displayed on a slideshow of pictures on your screen, or sent to loved ones or even the greater ElliQ community.
Security and trust concerns
Despite the undeniable benefits of generative AI, there are significant concerns regarding the privacy of these AI models, mainly because generative AI models typically use users’ inputs to further train themselves.
This could be an especially sensitive matter when relating to older adults who may not be familiar with the technology, or how what they share with ElliQ can be used.
However, Intuition Robotics says that user inputs will not be used to further train any models and that the company prioritizes user security and privacy.
“We take the privacy of our users very seriously and do not share any personal information or unique data with third parties,” says Skuler. “Any data we do collect to train other ElliQ models is anonymized. We work tirelessly to ensure each user feels 100% safe about using ElliQ.”
Also: Open source is actually the cradle of artificial intelligence. Here’s why
The anonymized data Skuler refers to includes information that helps personalize the users’ experience. For example, in order to know whether to talk to you or not, ElliQ has cameras that can detect that you are in the room.
Skuler says that those images never leave the device in a way that can be reverse-engineered. Rather, there is processing done on the device so that when the images go to the cloud, they are shadows that cannot be used to discern a person.
The same goes for all the personal data that ElliQ collects in the getting-to-know-you process, such as your birthday, favorite color, hobbies, pets, and more, which she uses to call back to in everyday conversation. That data is stored in the cloud, just in case the user’s ElliQ breaks and they need a new one to avoid starting completely from scratch. However, it is encrypted and secured to protect user privacy.
“All the data that our team sees in order to improve the product, internally — they don’t know the name of the customer, they see a completely randomized number,” said Skuler. “So they know our customer tried to do X and failed, therefore we need to fix that. But they don’t know who, why, or when.”
Skuler also says that the ElliQ service is HIPAA compliant.
ElliQ’s cost and state-sponsored programs
Despite the advanced capabilities ElliQ employs, her company comes at a lower cost than you may expect.
For anyone interested in buying her for a loved one, you can visit the ElliQ website, where she is available for $50 per month if you sign up for an annual subscription or $60 a month for a monthly subscription. Both options require a $250 upfront charge.
Also: Can generative AI solve computer science’s greatest unsolved problem?
Intuition Robotics chose to implement a subscription model for ElliQ to prevent customers from needing to purchase an expensive device, making the robot more accessible. Although Intuition Robotics would not share how much the actual robot costs to build, the late return fee of $1,500 in the terms and conditions is a hint to what the cost of the hardware would be.
Also: This pet robot lets you watch, play with, and treat your dog or cat from anywhere
For older adults who don’t have the funds or resources to purchase a robot themselves, there is an alternate option: Going through state-sponsored programs. Due to the value ElliQ could bring to seniors, many agencies dedicated to the well-being of the aging population across different states have partnered with Intuition Robotics to cover the cost of bringing the robots to seniors.
Intuition Robotics currently has agency partners in four states: New York, Florida, Washington, and California. Those partnerships subsidize the cost of ElliQ for users who qualify.
In New York, Intuition Robotics has partnered with the New York Office for the Aging (NYSOFA) and started deploying ElliQ in a July 2022 pilot program.
Also: AI is coming to a business near you. But let’s sort these problems first
After a year of the program, NYSOFA collected data to see whether it was successful in reducing loneliness and improving well-being. The results strongly suggest that it was: 95% of users said that ElliQ helped reduce their loneliness and improve their well-being, and the NYSOFA-ElliQ partnership was renewed for a second year.
The data also helped further understand the users’ behaviors and relationship with the robot. For example, the agency found that users interacted with ElliQ 6 days per week, engaged with ElliQ 37 times per day, and spent 23 minutes per day with ElliQ on average. Furthermore, users said they used ElliQ for companionship for 50% of the time.
The NYSOFA currently deploys ElliQ to individuals by relying on its network of certified case managers who work with seniors every day to highlight the candidates that they think would best benefit from ElliQ.
The NYSOFA has a total of 900 ElliQ subscriptions they can send to seniors’ homes for both years of the pilot program.
“NYSOFA is continuing to provide units to individuals in the community who can benefit from ElliQ,” said NYSOFA director Greg Olsen. “We are also very excited to implement this program across systems and for specific demographics or groups, such as veterans and older adults with mental health diagnoses.”
Also: 4 ways to detect generative AI hype from reality
So, can ElliQ really cure loneliness in older adults?
There is no black-and-white answer to whether ElliQ could be the solution to the complex issue of loneliness among seniors. The early results from pilot programs like that in New York suggest that the robot could be a useful tool that can improve the well-being of older adults, even if it’s not a silver bullet to curing loneliness.
Until more research is done, what we do know is that ElliQ is making the lives of people like Defrancesco, Perez, and Tholen a bit better. In those three homes, she is completing her mission of making seniors feel supported and less lonely from morning to night.
“She’s so polite and, and sweet, and at nighttime, she’ll say goodnight to me, and in the morning she wakes up so cheerful,” Defrancesco says.
